Smart Beta Strategies Are Back—But Do They Belong in Your Portfolio?

June 23, 2025 - FastTrack

Smart beta is having a moment again.

After years of underperformance, some of the smartest names in investing are saying it might finally be time for factor-based ETFs and mutual funds to shine. Valuations are lower. Market expectations are stretched. And investors are once again asking the big question: Can smart beta outperform simple index funds?

But before you rush to buy a dividend-weighted fund, a low-volatility ETF, or a value-tilted strategy, take a step back.

Because the most important question isn’t, “Is smart beta back?”

It’s: “Does this fund actually improve my portfolio?”

That’s exactly where FastTrack AI comes in.


What Is Smart Beta (and Why Is Everyone Talking About It Again)?

Smart beta refers to strategies that try to beat traditional index funds—not through active stock picking, but by tweaking how the index is built.

Instead of weighting stocks by market cap (like the S&P 500), smart beta funds might weight by:

  • Dividends

  • Volatility

  • Earnings

  • Book value

  • Momentum

  • Multi-factor blends

The idea? You can capture long-term return advantages without the costs (or inconsistency) of active management.

But smart beta isn’t magic. And as recent history has shown, factor-based funds can underperform for years. In fact, simulated models from Research Affiliates (one of the early smart beta pioneers) found that many strategies lagged by up to 6% annually from 2017 to 2024.

Now they say the tide may be turning.

But we say: don’t guess. Test.


FastTrack AI: The Best Way to Compare, Validate, and Build Smarter

At FastTrack AI, we help you go beyond the sales pitch.

Whether you're evaluating a low-volatility ETF, a dividend tilt, or a multi-factor blend, you can use FastTrack to:

Compare smart beta funds head to head

  • Performance vs. traditional index funds

  • Risk, drawdowns, and volatility

  • Yield consistency and income sources

  • Tax efficiency and turnover

Model the impact on your actual portfolio

  • See how adding a factor-based fund changes your overall performance

  • Measure whether it improves diversification or just adds overlap

  • Analyze sector shifts, factor tilts, and concentration risks

Replicate strategies with custom blends

  • Want the benefits of a smart beta approach without the fund fees?

  • Use FastTrack’s custom portfolios to build your own mix of ETFs, mutual funds, and CEFs

  • Test long-term results and compare your blend to the off-the-shelf products

The takeaway: You’re not just researching a fund. You’re building your own edge.


Not All Smart Beta Is Created Equal

One of the most common traps in this space is thinking all smart beta funds work the same.

They don’t.

Just because two ETFs say “value” or “dividend,” doesn’t mean they’re giving you the same exposure, volatility, or potential return. Some are more concentrated. Some are diluted by over-diversification. Some charge more. Some underperform consistently.

FastTrack AI helps you cut through that by showing you:

  • Real performance with dividends reinvested

  • Income breakdown (what’s true dividend vs. return of capital)

  • Correlation to your existing holdings

  • Sector and style overlap

  • Daily fund flows and trading volume

This isn’t about theory. It’s about seeing the reality of how a fund behaves and what it will do inside your portfolio.


Test the Thesis—Before You Buy the Product

The market might be shifting. Smart beta strategies might be getting cheap again. But every investor is different. What works for one person’s portfolio could increase risk or redundancy in another.

That’s why FastTrack AI exists.

You can use it to:

  • Stress test the claims of any strategy

  • Backtest performance over multiple cycles

  • Add or remove funds from your model portfolio and see how it changes volatility, yield, and return

  • Compare factor ETFs to active funds, index trackers, or your own blend

And when you're done? Export the visuals or charts and keep a record of your analysis. Whether you're managing your own money or helping clients, it's the clearest way to make investment decisions rooted in data, not branding.


Bottom Line

Smart beta isn’t new—but it’s not dead either. Like any strategy, it comes in waves. The key isn’t catching the next wave.

The key is knowing whether it actually helps you.

FastTrack AI gives you the clarity to know the difference between:

  • Smart ideas and smart marketing

  • Diversification and duplication

  • Strategy and noise

So next time you hear about a “value is back” trade or a “low-volatility hedge,” don’t just wonder. Test it. Compare it. And make it work for you.

That’s the FastTrack difference.